Sunday, January 22, 2023

The Morning: Peru’s deadly protests

A failed coup attempt set off unrest across the country.

First, a breaking news update: At least 10 people were killed in a shooting just east of Los Angeles. Read more details below, and follow The Times's updates.

Good morning. Demonstrations have immobilized Peru after the ouster of the country's populist president.

Protesters using stones to block the main road between Arequipa and Juliaca, Peru.Federico Rios Escobar for The New York Times

An immobilized country

President Pedro Castillo borrowed from history when he attempted a coup in Peru.

Thirty years ago, another president asserted authoritarian control. But this time, there was a critical difference: As president, Castillo had no support for his coup. The military and the judiciary quickly rejected his attempt last month.

Castillo's dramatic fall from power shook Peru, a country of 33 million people that is the fifth-most populous in Latin America. His supporters have protested across the country and at least 55 people have been killed, often in clashes with security forces.

I spoke with Julie Turkewitz, The Times's Andes bureau chief, about what she has seen reporting on the demonstrations and what the unrest reveals about democracy in South America.

Lauren: One newsletter described Castillo's ouster this way: "He had breakfast as a president, lunch as a dictator, dinner as a detainee." Tell me the story of his failed coup.

Julie: Castillo was a leftist from a poor, rural farming background. He was the surprise winner of the 2021 presidential election. A year later he was struggling to govern. In a shocking move, he announced on national television that he was dissolving Congress and that he would create a government that would rule by decree. This was widely seen as an illegal power grab. He was, in a matter of hours, impeached, arrested and taken to a detention center. His vice president was sworn in to replace him.

How did Peruvians respond?

Many of Castillo's supporters are poor or middle class Indigenous people, part of the roughly two-thirds of the country's population living outside of the capital, Lima. As a colleague of mine put it, many feel politically excluded while also feeling tokenized by Peru's tourism industry. When news reached his supporters in rural areas, they were angry he had been removed from office. Castillo was their hope for change.

So tens of thousands of protesters took to the streets in an effort to shut down the country, what they felt was their only way to be heard. People started blocking the highways with broken glass, boulders or burning tires. There are now protests or blockades in about 40 percent of Peru's provinces.

While some people living in urban areas dismissed these demonstrators as extremists, at least one trusted poll shows a majority of Peruvians support the protests.

What has the government done to address this unrest?

The new president, Dina Boluarte, called a national state of emergency, an exceptional measure limiting guarantees to certain civil rights. The protests only got bigger and more violent. The police and military were sent to try to restore order in rural areas, and they responded at times with extraordinary violence. Security forces shot some in the chest, back and head.

You went to Juliaca, a southern city where 19 people were killed on Jan. 9. How did you get there if the protesters shut down highways and immobilized the country?

My colleagues and I persuaded protesters to let us through roadblocks by carrying printed copies of our previous stories, often talking with demonstrators for hours. It was night when we finally arrived to Juliaca after nine hours of driving. The street was blocked with part of a rusted amusement-park ride, chicken wire and small fires. It really felt like we'd arrived at the end of times.

What did you find in the morning?

We woke up in the Andes at nearly 13,000 feet above sea level. Juliaca is a city of extremes: The sun feels closer, harsher. The wind is cutting, dusty and cold. One of the first things that we saw when we left the hotel was a spontaneous march happening in the streets.

There were young people in skinny jeans and older women in traditional skirts, braids and hats. Together, they blamed the new president for the protesters' deaths and said, "This democracy is no longer a democracy."

What did you learn from speaking with protesters?

Being there helped me understand why people feel the Peruvian democracy is not working for them. People feel the system is rigged against them. And on the ground, I could really see why they believed that.

What did you see?

We found one example when we went to a public hospital and spoke to many people who had suffered gunshot wounds in the city's deadly protest. Human rights groups have accused police of shooting directly at demonstrators. The wounded had not been given their medical reports, even though that was their right. Several people said they believed that they were being punished for their association with the demonstrations.

At the hospital, patients lacked access to basic services. They pay for their own water and there is no toilet paper or soap in many hospital bathrooms. The hospital director, appointed by the government, said, basically, everything is fine here. He didn't tell me that the victims needed more help. This idea that people feel forgotten by Peruvian democracy was visible in the hospital.

Are there similarities between this unrest and other protests across the continent?

That disaffection is a problem we're seeing across South America, including in Chile, Colombia and Brazil. What is distinct about this unrest compared with Brazil's riots is that misinformation fueled the storming of Brazil's capital. The overarching story in Peru is more about decades of frustration over poverty, inequality and dysfunction.

You have written that these protests are a referendum on Peru's democracy. How so?

Just 21 percent of people in Peru are satisfied with their democracy, according to a Vanderbilt University survey. The path forward isn't clear. I spoke with one of the world's leading democracy experts, Steve Levitsky. He says you need two things for democracy to die: First, you need a widespread belief that the democracy isn't working for most people. Peru has that. But the other thing you need is a viable alternative. And a viable alternative just doesn't exist right now.

More about Julie: Based in Bogotá, she covers Colombia, Venezuela, Peru, Ecuador and Bolivia. Before moving to South America, she covered the U.S. West.

Related: Police raided a university in Lima to crack down on protests and closed Machu Picchu indefinitely, The Guardian reported.

ADVERTISEMENT

NEWS

California Shooting
The investigation scene this morning.Caroline Brehman/EPA, via Shutterstock
  • At least 10 people were killed and 10 injured in a shooting in Monterey Park, east of Los Angeles.
  • The gunman opened fire at a dance studio, the Los Angeles Times reported. Witnesses said he appeared to shoot indiscriminately.
  • A Lunar New Year festival had been held hours earlier nearby in the city, which has a largely Asian American population.
Politics
War in Ukraine
Other Big Stories

FROM OPINION

Nancy Pelosi spoke about leaving Democratic leadership ("upward and onward") and the men who tried to hamper her political rise ("poor babies") in an interview with Maureen Dowd.

This century's defining challenge isn't climate change; it's demographic decline as societies age, Ross Douthat argues.

We know how to save hungry children. As famine looms in Somalia, acting early is crucial, Nicholas Kristof writes.

The Sunday question: The debt limit threatens the economy. Is there a better way?

Replacing the debt ceiling with a "debt brake" would limit spending without political brinkmanship, Steve Hanke and Barry Poulson argue in National Review. Or Congress could simply abolish it, Karen Dolan notes in The Hill.

Explore all The New York Times has to offer with All Access — News, plus Games, Cooking, Wirecutter and The Athletic — at a special rate. Subscribe today.

MORNING READS

Mark Kolbe/Getty Images

Fashion ace: The U.S. tennis star Frances Tiafoe lost at the Australian Open, but his swirly look was a winner.

Stargazing: Watch a green-hued comet pass by earth for the first time since the Stone Age. Here's how to see it.

Vows: Four cross-cultural celebrations on three continents.

Sunday routine: For one day a week, a cookie entrepreneur doesn't set an alarm.

Advice from Wirecutter: Make your sleeper sofa more comfortable.

ADVERTISEMENT

BOOKS

Finding community: The journalist John Hendrickson got Biden to open up about his stutter. Now he's written about his own.

A Kremlinologist: A novel exploring Vladimir Putin's motivations is reshaping the French debate over the war in Ukraine.

By the Book: Aleksandar Hemon is not a fan of Philip Roth.

Our editors' picks: "Ghost Music," an atmospheric novel about mysterious packages, and eight other books.

Times best sellers: "Hell Bent," the second book in Leigh Bardugo's Alex Stern series, took the top spot on the hardcover fiction list.

THE SUNDAY TIMES MAGAZINE

Photo illustration by Justin Metz

On the cover: What can Tesla's blind spots on its self-driving cars teach us about Elon Musk?

Recommendation: Rogaine is for everyone.

Ethicist: Is it OK to let relatives think their dead sister is still alive? (To read more Ethicist columns, sign up for the new Ethicist newsletter.)

THE WEEK AHEAD

What to Watch For
  • Activists plan to march today in dozens of cities to mark the 50th anniversary of Roe v. Wade.
  • The Lunar New Year begins today.
  • The Senate Judiciary Committee will hold a hearing on Tuesday on Ticketmaster's hold over the entertainment industry after the company's flawed rollout of Taylor Swift concert tickets.
  • Oscar nominations will be announced on Tuesday.
  • The Australian Open women's final is set for Saturday, and the men's final for one day later.
What to Cook This Week
Bobbi Lin for The New York Times. Food Stylist: Eugene Jho.

It's citrus season, and Emily Weinstein's weeknight dishes newsletter features zesty recipes to break out of the winter stew rut. There's pan-seared fish with pesto; spicy skirt steak, cooked under the broiler with tangerines; and sheet-pan lemony chicken with brussels sprouts. (The sprouts are optional if you're feeding picky eaters.)

NOW TIME TO PLAY

The pangram from yesterday's Spelling Bee was arachnid. Here is today's puzzle.

Here's today's Mini Crossword, and a clue: Result of brainstorming (four letters).

Take the news quiz to see how well you followed the week's headlines.

Thanks for spending part of your weekend with The Times.

Lauren Hard, Claire Moses, Ian Prasad Philbrick, Tom Wright-Piersanti and Ashley Wu contributed to The Morning. You can reach the team at themorning@nytimes.com.

Need help? Review our newsletter help page or contact us for assistance.

You received this email because you signed up for the Morning newsletter from The New York Times, or as part of your New York Times account.

To stop receiving The Morning, unsubscribe. To opt out of other promotional emails from The Times, manage your email preferences.

Subscribe to The Times

Connect with us on:

facebooktwitterinstagram

Change Your EmailPrivacy PolicyContact UsCalifornia Notices

LiveIntent LogoAdChoices Logo

The New York Times Company. 620 Eighth Avenue New York, NY 10018

No comments:

Page List

Blog Archive

Search This Blog

Americans Are Panic Buying Toilet Paper Again And F1 Teams Up With LV

Newsletter Oct 3, 2024 ...