Monday, December 2, 2024

On Politics: Biden the father vs. Biden the institutionalist

Tension between parenthood and politics has defined the Biden presidency.
On Politics

December 2, 2024

In a black-and-white photo, Joe Biden stands over his son Beau, who is lying in a bed with his leg in a sling, as 3-year-old Hunter, right, points at his brother.
In 1973, Joe Biden was with his sons Beau, left, and Hunter in the hospital as they recovered from a car crash that had killed their mother. He was sworn in as a senator there, so they could be with him. Jodi Cobb/The News Journal, via USA Today Network

The father vs. the institutionalist

The latest

On the day President Biden's career in national politics began in 1973, he walked up to a lectern set up in a Delaware hospital room while holding his 3-year-old son, Hunter, in his arms. Both Hunter and his older brother Beau, who was lying in a hospital bed nearby, were recovering after being in a car accident that had killed their sister and mother weeks earlier.

Biden was there to take the oath to become a senator, a ceremony held at the hospital so his sons could be there. And, he suggested, if there was ever a "conflict between my being a good father and being a good senator," he would step aside.

He never did, but a tension between parenthood and politics would come to define his presidency.

On Sunday, nearly 52 years after taking that oath and now nearing the end of his political career, he again held up Hunter, at least symbolically, pardoning his son for a decade of legal trouble that included federal convictions on gun and tax charges.

It was an extraordinary move that came after he and his press secretary repeatedly insisted he would not pardon his son. It seemed to upend Biden's attempts to portray himself as an institutionalist. But it wasn't a surprise to those who have observed his relationship with his son.

My colleague Katie Rogers is a White House correspondent who has written extensively about Biden and his family. We talked today about how Biden's complex relationship with his son set the stage for a pardon that has drawn bipartisan condemnation. Our conversation was condensed and edited for clarity.

JB: Biden has long said he would not pardon his son. What do we know about why he ultimately decided to do so?

KR: I think that Biden's thinking on this has evolved as outside circumstances have changed. He was adamant that he would not issue a pardon as president in the summer, when Hunter was convicted on federal gun charges. But a lot has changed as summer turned into fall. Biden dropped out of the presidential race. The vice president's campaign failed, and a former president, Donald Trump, was elected while promising to stock his administration with vengeful characters who were making no secret of their interest in going after political enemies. The only thing that hadn't really changed was Hunter's legal circumstances.

It's always been a hugely distracting thing for the president. For the better part of last week, he was with his wife, Jill Biden, and Hunter in Nantucket. The first lady had been supportive of a pardon. Hunter Biden has certainly been in support of a pardon for himself. And surrounded by family, the president finalized that decision on Saturday night and told his senior aides on a conference call that it was "time to end all of this."

Hunter Biden has been a Republican attack line, a media story line and a presence in the White House. How has Hunter shaped his father's presidency, and how has his father responded to the focus on his son?

Hunter is in the center of his father's circle of trust, as was his older brother, Beau, who died of brain cancer in 2015. He has weighed in on speeches, particularly those that deal with the fight for democracy. Hunter was one of the only people in the room with his father when he made the final decision to drop out of the presidential race, and Hunter was in the room with the president when he neared this decision to pardon him.

He has unfettered access to his father, and with that comes access to some of the biggest decisions he's made as president and as a presidential candidate. The Bidens have always been really palpably defensive of Hunter, whether it's about his addiction issues or his influence with his father. It is really the one line they don't let anybody cross with them.

I think critics and allies alike would say that's an enormous blind spot. It's also something that Biden aides have to clean up retroactively, which is something the press secretary is having to do today, as the president is making one of the most potentially damaging decisions to his legacy.

How have the criminal and political investigations of Hunter Biden weighed on his father?

The president believes that Hunter was singled out only because he's the president's son, and I think President Biden, publicly and privately, feels enormous guilt over Hunter's legal problems. One of the president's allies told me this afternoon that the president's decision can't be defended, only explained — and that his love for his son is so powerful that he's willing to take the heat that's going to come from this.

Are we seeing a conflict between Biden the institutionalist — a guy who loves to uphold the nation's political norms — and Biden the father?

We're not even seeing a conflict. We're seeing which side won out. Those two parts of him are always in tension with the other, especially since Hunter's addiction problems really came to the fore.

People who know the president and talk to him — these are people who love him, his allies — say it's no surprise that this was coming. It was just a matter of when the anguished father would overtake the politician who has been promising principled leadership.

A survey by the Pew Research Center this year found that 42 percent of Trump's supporters believed it would be acceptable for him to pardon family, friends or political supporters who have been convicted of a crime. Only 8 percent of Harris supporters believed that about her. How has Trump — who pardoned his son-in-law's father, after all — made this easier for Biden in a sense?

It's not unheard of for presidents to do this. Republican voters have already seen Trump pardon people close to him. Bill Clinton pardoned his half brother. But I think one of the more influential factors, even than Trump setting the terms, is Trump's promises to install people in the government who would basically eliminate checks on the system Biden said he wanted to defend.

The statement we saw from Biden was laced with bitterness and even cynicism about the legal system, as it stands now. I think it came from an embittered president, and an anguished father.

What do we know about Hunter Biden's reaction to all of this?

Hunter issued a statement last night saying that he was going to dedicate his life to making things better for people like him, and that he was going to find some purpose in this. He has not answered my questions today, but I think he's a grateful and relieved son today. His father has made one of the most politically impactful decisions of a half-century career to benefit his son.

I would imagine there's immense relief for Hunter. I don't know if the president feels the same.

One Story You Shouldn't Miss

MORE POLITICS NEWS AND ANALYSIS

A photo of the conservative filmmaker Dinesh D'Souza.

Lucas Jackson/Reuters

Director of '2000 Mules' Acknowledges the Conspiratorial Film Was Flawed

The director, Dinesh D'Souza, who is facing a lawsuit over the documentary, admitted that an analysis used to make claims about election fraud that were later debunked had been faulty.

By Nick Corasaniti and Ken Bensinger

Lights are on inside voting booths, all empty and lined up in front of a wall. There are cabinets and a wall on the wall.

Jenn Ackerman for The New York Times

What's Next in U.S. Elections: Races to Watch in 2025

Virginia and New Jersey feature contests for governor. Elections in Wisconsin and Pennsylvania could tip the power balance on the Supreme Court in those battleground states.

By Neil Vigdor

People in a hallway at the Democratic National Convention, with TV screens above them showing Gov. Josh Shapiro of Pennsylvania giving his speech.

Jamie Kelter Davis for The New York Times

For Rising Democrats, the Quiet Race to Lead the Party Began Months Ago

As Kamala Harris dominated attention on the 2024 trail, ambitious Democrats were also blanketing the country, building relationships that could pay dividends in the fight for the party's future.

By Katie Glueck

Robert F. Kennedy Jr., wearing a jacket and tie, speaks into a microphone with a few people surrounding him in the spin room after a debate.

Kenny Holston/The New York Times

Kennedy's Inheritance: How Addiction and Trauma Shaped a Turbulent Life

Donald Trump's pick to be health secretary, Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has reached a pinnacle of power after a life of fame and addictions and a career intertwined with conspiracy theories.

By Sheryl Gay Stolberg, Susanne Craig and Rebecca Davis O'Brien

Two portraits — one of Martin O'Malley on the left, and another of Ken Martin on the right.

Anna Rose Layden/Getty Images; Jenn Ackerman for The New York Times

Who Might Be the Next Chair of the Democratic Party?

The current leader of the Democratic National Committee, Jaime Harrison, won't seek re-election. His successor will need to revive a distressed party.

By Simon J. Levien

Read past editions of the newsletter here.

If you're enjoying what you're reading, please consider recommending it to others. They can sign up here.

Have feedback? Ideas for coverage? We'd love to hear from you. Email us at onpolitics@nytimes.com.

Nate Cohn, The Times's chief political analyst, makes sense of the latest political data.

Try four weeks of complimentary access to The Tilt

Nate Cohn, The Times's chief political analyst, makes sense of the latest political data.

Get it in your inbox
A square filled with smaller squares and rectangles in shades of red and blue.

Need help? Review our newsletter help page or contact us for assistance.

You received this email because you signed up for On Politics from The New York Times.

To stop receiving On Politics, unsubscribe. To opt out of other promotional emails from The Times, including those regarding The Athletic, manage your email settings. To opt out of updates and offers sent from The Athletic, submit a request.

Subscribe to The Times

Connect with us on:

facebookxinstagramwhatsapp

Change Your EmailPrivacy PolicyContact UsCalifornia Notices

LiveIntent LogoAdChoices Logo

The New York Times Company. 620 Eighth Avenue New York, NY 10018

No comments:

Page List

Blog Archive

Search This Blog

U.S. Department of Justice Attorney Vacancies Update

You are subscribed to Attorney Vacancies for U.S. Department of Justice. This information has recently been up...